TL;DR: Take detailed photos and videos when you move in and move out. I was charged for damage I did not cause and my documentation is the reason I’m challenging it. I would strongly encourage future residents to thoroughly document both move-in and move-out conditions with photos and videos. I moved out on April 30, 2026 and left the apartment in excellent condition. During my tenancy, I never had a late payment and took great care of the unit. Four days after I moved out, management finally contacted me to schedule a joint move-out inspection. However, I was later informed that management had already entered the apartment and conducted its own inspection before reaching out to me, despite knowing my vacate date was April 30th. I was subsequently charged $542.72 for a refrigerator repair and provided with a photo of a very small alleged dent that management claims I caused. None of my move-out photos or videos reflect the condition shown in management’s photo, and I dispute responsibility for the charge. After requesting documentation and disputing the deduction, management formally declined to reverse the charge. As a result, I will be pursuing the matter in small claims court. Regardless of the outcome, my advice to future residents is simple: take extensive photos and videos of every room, appliance, and surface before turning in your keys. I will include management’s photo of the alleged dent as well as photos showing the condition in which I left the unit. The tiny dent is their photo…the others are mine.


The Alistair Apartments offers luxury studio and one-bedroom apartments for rent in Lancaster, PA, with a distinctive design-forward feel in the heart of downtown. Warm white-oak paneling, a boho-inspired lobby and carefully considered interiors create an atmosphere that feels more boutique hotel than conventional apartment building. Apartments feature quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances and in-unit laundry. Residents enjoy a fitness center, rooftop deck, garage parking, EV charging, storage, indoor bike storage, secure building access and pet-friendly living. Walk to Penn Medicine Lancaster General Hospital, Central Market, Penn Square, Fulton Theatre, restaurants, shops and entertainment. Contact us for availability or tours.
Gallery
ReviewsGoogle Maps
My experience at The Alistair has been genuinely positive. The property is modern, well-maintained, and managed with a level of professionalism that is easy to appreciate. My apartment is comfortable, thoughtfully designed, and finished with details that make everyday living smooth. The community has a balanced mix of residents, and the atmosphere stays respectful. Shared spaces are consistently kept in excellent condition. Management is a standout — clear communication, reliable follow‑through, and quick responses when something needs attention. That consistency sets the tone for the whole place. The location fits well with my lifestyle and makes day‑to‑day errands simple. Overall, The Alistair has been a great fit for me: a well-managed, comfortable community that I’m pleased to call home.
Love the location being downtown and the views are beautiful. I enjoy being able to walk around stores/restaurants and Wegmans is just 5 minutes away!
Showing 3 of 16: the first written reviews in Google's order, most relevant first.
Read all 16 reviews on Google →Book an appointment
Follow us
Find us
17603
On the van, cards and invoices. One scan opens everything above.